This episode was written & produced by Katie Clark Gray and Casey Emmerling.
In Part 2 of our 10th anniversary story, Dallas reveals how Twenty Thousand Hertz grew from an expensive passion project into a thriving podcast. From early experiments in tone and style, to landmark episodes about Netflix and Game of Thrones, he revisits the breakthroughs that helped define the show… before revealing why it almost came to an end. Along the way, he shares a private recording from our most uncertain moment, the unexpected lifeline that kept the show going, and his vision for a more human future.
MUSIC FEATURED IN THIS EPISODE
Wesley Slover - Just Facts 04
Wesley Slover - Fruity Riff
Wesley Slover - Smooth As a Stone
Wesley Slover - Fun Secrets
Wesley Slover - It’s Invisible
Wesley Slover - After the Fire
Wesley Slover - One Sec
Wesley Slover - Me and My Robot
Wesley Slover - Dropmire
Wesley Slover - Nightfall Neighborhood
Wesley Slover - The Work
Wesley Slover - Prism
Wesley Slover - WFH Casual
Wesley Slover - New Package
Wesley Slover - Contemplative Spirit X
Wesley Slover - Everyday Symphony
Twenty Thousand Hertz is produced by Defacto Sound.
Support the show and get ad-free episodes at 20k.org/plus.
Subscribe on YouTube to see our video series.
Follow Dallas on Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, and LinkedIn.
If you know what this week's mystery sound is, tell us at mystery.20k.org.
Shop incredible speakers and soundbars from Sonos at sonos.com.
To unlock an exclusive offer on Glean's enterprise AI, visit glean.com/20k.
Save up to 30% on Blueland cleaning essentials at blueland.com/20k.
Get three months of free payroll with Gusto at gusto.com/20k.
View Transcript ▶︎
Dallas: And then 10 years is here now. Here we are at 10 years. And that was my goal. If I could make it for 10 years, I feel like that that's a mark in podcasting history. And it's here now. And I just want to keep working hard, because I feel like there's still so much room to get better at this craft.
[music in: Wesley Slover - Just Facts 04]
Twenty Thousand Hertz is now 10 years old, and to mark the occasion, I wanted to tell the entire story of how I got here.
The last episode covered everything that led me to start the podcast… from my early life as a trumpet player, to how panic attacks forced me to give up on my music dreams, to my long journey into the world of post production sound, and how I started my company, Defacto Sound. At the end of that episode, I explained how we launched Twenty Thousand Hertz.
This episode is part 2 of that story. From episode one until now… plus a peek into the future of the show. It’s basically a peek behind the curtain of all of the ups and downs of what’s happened since I started the podcast ten years ago.
So a quick disclaimer, like last time, this episode is a little unusual… It's a mix of traditional narration, like I’m doing right now, as well as my more off-the-cuff interview with the producer of this episode, Katie. So an easy way to think of this is that I'm basically both the host and the guest.
Enjoy.
[music out]
Dallas: I always felt that there was a pilot right at the beginning because I didn't know if it was gonna go past 10 episodes. I just thought if I could make 10 episodes, I would've done the thing. You know, I would've put it out into the world.
[music in: Wesley Slover - Fruity Riff]
Dallas: So I made the first 10 episodes. We were trying different things. Some things I enjoyed, some things I didn't enjoy as much. There's a couple shows early in Twenty Thousand Hertz that I would not do today because they were too intense.
Dallas: I think about Twenty Thousand Hertz as being an escape from the real world. We live in a parallel universe where none of the bad, or at least the gut-churny things that we all gut churn over, none of that exists, and the only thing that matters is a celebration of arts and sound and music.
Dallas: So there are a few things early on that felt like we were dabbling too hard into NPR, I guess, for lack of a better term? Because that's what I was listening to at the time.
[clip: NPR]
NPR Clip: Here's what we know about the Amazon rainforest. It's huge, and it's disappearing.
[music out]
Early on, I worked with a branding agency called Identity Visuals to make a new Twenty Thousand Hertz icon. In it, we used expanding circles to evoke sound coming out of a speaker. You can actually see that version in the artwork for this episode. It’s close to our current icon, but a little bit more muted.
But the biggest struggle back then was our finances.
Dallas: I remember I was paying for it all, through a difficult time in my studio. Those first 10 to 20 episodes, I was really financially struggling. I think I spent like $50,000 in writing costs and labor costs that were just money going out. And that's money I really didn't have.
But then, something strange started happening.
[music in: Wesley Slover - Smooth As a Stone]
Dallas: I started getting these emails from these agencies that I'd never heard of. They were saying, "We want to put ads on your show."
Dallas: And at the time, I had no ad breaks because I didn't know how podcast advertising works. I kept getting these emails from, you know, Blue Apron or Casper Mattresses, and finally entertained one because I was just like, "This has gotta be a scam, but tell me more."
Dallas: Finally got on a call with one of these buyers and like,
Dallas: (phone processing) "No, this, we're the biggest agency in podcast advertising, and you should look us up. This is how the whole business works. This is how much you should charge." Really candid with me. And really thankful, because I think that that was the first time we got ads, and so that felt like I was getting a little bit of relief there. It was episode 10 that we had one Blue Apron ad.
Here's one of the first ads we ever ran, from 2017. Just like our episodes from back then, I wasn’t quite as good of a narrator. I hadn’t quite found my voice.
[early Blue Apron ad]
Blue Apron Ad: There’s nothing like coming home, driving up into the driveway, hungry, not knowing at all what I’m gonna eat, and seeing that Blue Apron sitting on my doorstep.
After that, we gradually started booking a few more.
Dallas: And it was literally like the classics. It was like Blue Apron, Skillshare, Audible, Squarespace. And that only would pay for, gosh, maybe like one-fifth the cost of making it. But it was still something.
[music out]
But in mid-2017, we landed a deal with a major audio brand that filled over six months’ worth of ad space.
Dallas: They came in and effectively paid for 13 episodes.
Between that booking, and a few others around that time, Twenty Thousand Hertz gradually shifted from being a passion project that was draining my savings… to something that might have a viable future.
Dallas: 2018 was when it felt like it was a real podcast. We were just jam-packed with ads. I'm doing cross-promos with some of my favorite podcasts.
Cross-promos are basically when you hear a podcaster recommend another show you should check out. Meanwhile, the host of that podcast will recommend the other show to their listeners. It’s kind of like a “You scratch my back, I scratch yours” situation.
Dallas: Like I'm doing Side Door, Switched on Pop, Business Wars, Darknet Diaries, that's huge now.
[clip: Darknet Diaries promo]
Darknet Diaries Promo: I wanna tell you about a podcast that I think you’ll like. It’s called Darknet Diaries and features stories about hackers and cybercrimes.
Dallas: So it's like I'm swapping now with legit podcasts that I love. But we all were kind of up and coming at that time and trying to help each other. I don't know, it was just so fun.
[music in: Wesley Slover - Fun Secrets]
At this point, we were still experimenting with what a quote unquote show about sound could even mean. Sometimes we went into a topic, or a location, with no absolutely no plan at all.
Dallas: One of my favorite is that I went to the White House. I had a friend of mine who was the videographer for Obama's last year and a half, and he gave me a private tour of the West Wing twice. I go in thinking I wanted to make a show about the sound of the White House. Now, is there any storyline there? No.
[HVAC hum in]
Dallas: The AC system sounded really unique to me. It was very, very intense. Or I, I should just say the HVAC. The ventilation systems sounded like they were probably much more next level than your normal ventilation systems.
[HVAC hum out]
Dallas: I'll leave it at that. I got no more information, nor would anyone tell me anything like that, because trying to go into the White House and just get a story with no one knowing about it is not really something you do.
[music buttons into hushed voices]
Dallas: So I went in and I was recording, and he was like, "You can't use any of this tape. That's the Secretary of State right there talking about this Russia thing that's happening. This is all confidential. You can't do this."
Dallas: And so all I'm doing is just hanging out with people, all of his friends. But in that moment, my friend told me the story of how Michelle Obama's Twitter account randomly just tweeted out my friend's phone number with no context. And it was up for like six minutes on Twitter, from Michelle Obama. And the entire news world started covering it, and digging into this guy's life, and that was one of my favorite episodes.
[clip: 314-914-6093]
Duncan Wolfe: My phone’s buzzing and I look up at it and it’s some unknown phone number from Nebraska or something. And I’m having a conversation with somebody, unknown phone number, it’s like “press decline.” And as soon as I press decline there was another phone call, then it’s like as soon as you press decline another call’s there. Florida, decline. Montana, decline. Illinois, California, Nevada, Maine, South Dakota, Ohio, Florida again, Russia, Iran, the UK, Jamaica, Croatia…
Dallas: I remember that one being kind of one of the most experimental ones. Is it about sound? Really? It was… it was a departure. But again, this is episode 32, and we're still trying to, like, find our way of what works and what doesn't, and I wanted to stretch a little bit and see.
Dallas: But then that year, we're landing into stuff like Hamilton, The Amen Break, THX Deep Note, Loop Groups… We actually had an episode about ourselves on episode 50, which this episode kind of parallels.
[clip: Episode 50]
Episode 50: Defacto essentially just started as me, but has grown into this incredible sound team that we have now.
Jai: Defacto Sound does sound design and mixing for post production. Basically, we try to help tell someone’s narrative through sound.
My team and I were all established sound designers and mixers. And now, we were finding our voice as podcasters.
Dallas: One person I have to give massive credit to that's just totally unsung is Colin DeVarney, who has been here the entire time since the first episode, and he is also now the Audio Director of Defacto Sound. He wrote so many early episodes as a sound designer who moved across the country to work at Defacto Sound. He has always been just right there ready to cheerfully make a thing.
By 2019, it felt like we finally had flow. And I was capturing these untold stories behind the sounds shaping our culture. Like when I interviewed Paula Fairfield, the sound designer of Game of Thrones. She told me about how she gave voice to the show’s dragons and dire wolves. And I had no idea how emotional that would get.
Dallas: That was one that I was like, "Tell me how the cool dragon sounds came from." And then it was just the most heartbreaking of episodes, about how the sound designer put in a lot of her animals that she had since lost into the actual dragon sounds and dire wolf sounds, and it just… wrecked me.
Paula Fairfield: And then I had the opportunity to do the return of Nymeria scene, when she returns to visit Arya with her wolf pack. And every voice in that is my dog Angel.
Paula Fairfield: It was my love letter to her. For me, it was a big scene, because it was my way of saying goodbye to her.
Stories like that taught me that Twenty Thousand Hertz was about more than just how sounds are made. Sound is deeply connective to people… to their relationships, their memories, their joy, and their pain. These stories weren't being told anywhere else, and I started to feel a real heavy responsibility to capture them.
[music in: Wesley Slover - It’s Invisible]
Around this time, we worked with a freelance writer named Casey Emmerling. I gave him an episode topic that I wasn't sure was gonna work.
Dallas: I thought it was gonna be kind of boring, but I wanted to go with it, which was phone tones. Like, how did the phone tones, you know, (sfx: phone tones) beep, beep, beep, beep, beep, beep, beep. Like, what is that? How does that work?
Dallas: And I just remember getting the first pass from him and going like, "You get it." Like, "First pass, you are crushing on this. You made something that I thought was just gonna be semi-okay." And up to this point, I mean, we're 63 episodes in, and I'm doing every review, every writing review, all the story editing, every single review of audio, and it was just exhausting while trying to run a company.
Dallas: Casey comes in and crushes, so I start working with him a little bit more. But it was really clear that, like, he was the right person to really start taking the reins.
Eventually, Casey came on full-time as our Supervising Producer. And that meant that I finally wouldn't be stretched so thin.
[music out]
2019 becomes 2020. But then, COVID hits, and no one really knows what that will mean for podcasts. Will everyone's downloads plummet, because hardly anyone is commuting to work?
[music in: Wesley Slover - After the Fire]
Dallas: I thought that all of our traffic would decline, and I think it did at first. I'm pretty sure that, like, as soon as March hit, April, May, there was a little bit of like a dip.
Dallas: But I think that a lot of people started taking comfort in Twenty Thousand Hertz, because I, the only time I ever acknowledged the pandemic was one time. I just said, "I know what's going on. We are not gonna acknowledge it. This will be an escape."
[clip: 20K COVID announcement]
COVID Announcement: Before we get started, I’d like to address the elephant in the room. I know we’re all a bit freaked out by what’s happening with the caronavirus, and I don’t want you to think that we’re tone deaf to the situation. Personally, I feel that it’s important to stay informed on the circumstances. But I also need an escape. And since no one here at 20K HQ are experts in what’s happening right now, I feel like it’s our job to give you that escape. So that’s what we’re gonna do.
Dallas: We took every single show that we had that had any sort of sad theme and pushed them all to like years later, because every single podcast back then turned into the COVID cast. Everyone just zoomed in and focused on this thing, which I get. But at the moment, I was like, "I know people need to like not live this for 30 minutes."
[music out]
Dallas: April 1st of 2020 was when we did kind of an April Fools joke where we turned into a podcast about smell called "20 Parts Per Thousand."
COVID Announcement: You’re listening to Twenty Parts Per Thousand, the stories behind the world’s most recognizable and interesting smells.
Dallas: You know, this is April 1st. Like this is the saddest time. Then Mel Blanc was right after that, a two-part series. Pew Pew on Star Wars. Makin' Whoopee about whoopee cushions. The McElroy brothers on our game show.
Travis McElroy: Is it an ultrasound of a dolphin fart?
Dallas: It could be. Yeah.
Travis McElroy: You can't say, "It could be." It could be anything.
Justin McElroy: I'm going to go with dolphin fart so we can move on with our lives.
Dallas: It was like we're going all in on joy during this entire time. I remember telling the team, it is just:
[happy strings on each "joy"]
Dallas: "Joy, joy, joy, joy, joy, joy, joy, joy. It will be all joy all the time." And it was that whole year. And, we grew a lot through that streak too because I, I think that people needed that.
[music in: Wesley Slover - One Sec]
It was during this streak that the team and I started kicking around a question…
Dallas: And that is the Netflix tudum sound. Who made the Netflix “tuduuum”, and what's the story behind that? So I start going down this twisty, turny path, and I reach out to some of the audio people at Netflix and say, "Hey, I am trying to find, mystery of who made this sound."
Dallas: One of the people there said, "Hey, next time you're in Hollywood, stop by." And so I immediately, like, got on a flight, went out there because I was like, "I want to come hang out and learn about this."
So, I flew out to Netflix, and met with their team. But piecing the full story together took almost an entire year. In the end, we had the definitive origin story of one of the most recognizable sounds in modern history.
[clip: Tudum episode]
Tudum Narration: But what we can do is break down what this sound is actually made of. Here's sound designer Lon Bender.
Lon Bender: It’s a combination of music, and of the sound effects of these knocks which is my wedding ring that I’m wearing knocking on the side of a cabinet in our bedroom. (sfx) There was a slowed anvil sound which had a deeper tone. (sfx)
Tudum Narration: In addition to the ring and anvil, Lon also added a couple of muted hits to give it a little more oomph. (sfx)
And that story became our most downloaded episode of all time… Thanks in part to one ridiculous detail.
Dallas: The other thing is that there used to be a goat at the end of it, where it would be like "Tuduuum… baa." Seriously. Because he was trying to do a callback like Leo the Lion from MGM.
[clip MGM Logo]
Dallas: Not only that, I played a recreation of what I heard because quite literally the PR person said, "I cannot send you this file, but this, I promise you this is real. Here, listen on a Zoom call," and played the "Da-dum baa."
Now obviously, Netflix didn't end up going with the goat idea. But that little factoid got tons of press. Websites like Entertainment Weekly, The Hollywood Reporter, Huffington Post and IGN all wrote articles about it, where had linked to our episode. It's the most news attention we ever got before or since.
[music in: Wesley Slover - Me and My Robot]
By this point, the reach of Twenty Thousand Hertz was attracting new clients to Defacto Sound. From tiny production studios, to giant streamers and global brands, people were hearing these stories, and reaching out to work with us. And in turn, that money helped fortify the podcast.
Dallas: I've always said that a healthy Twenty Thousand Hertz is only on the back of a healthy Defacto Sound. Uh, if we have good clients at Defacto Sound, we're able to subsidize the podcast and keep that afloat.
This period of 2021 to 2022 was really the Golden Age for highly produced podcasts. And throughout that time, Twenty Thousand Hertz was more or less thriving. Our listenership and ad revenue were both at an all-time high. I was getting unprecedented access to tell these stories… like getting invited into Apple's private keynote events, and touring Hans Zimmer's music studio.
We were winning awards, and collaborating with huge shows like Planet Money and The Happiness Lab. And it really felt like we were fulfilling our mission: which is getting more people to care about the world of sound.
And then, the Golden Age ended, and the bottom dropped out.
[music abrupt out]
Dallas: It was just gut churn and intensity and almost just like walls closing in for months, and I realize, “I've gotta end the show.”
That's coming up, after the break.
[music in: Wesley Slover - Dropmire]
Dallas: 2021 was the peak of our listenership and the peak of pretty much all podcast listenership. 2021, maybe 2022, and then you can look at anyone's curve and everyone starts to decline from there.
It's not just one thing that happens; it's more like a cascade. In 2023, several major podcast networks collapse, when the corporations that own them decide they're not as profitable as they had hoped. Then, Apple makes a backend change that reduces automatic episode downloads… which causes everyone's listener numbers to drop.
Dallas: They measure downloads differently. Things become standardized. These are probably good things because if someone says they have a million downloads, that doesn't necessarily mean a million people listened to it. So we're standardizing what an ad impression can be because the measurement of how valuable you are as a podcast is the impression, not the quality.
Dallas: So we are over here making podcasts every two weeks that take 200 to 300 hours of deep research to make. Meanwhile, there are other podcasts from comedians that they can pump out five a week, and do no production, and have 10 times more impressions on every single episode.
Dallas: So they have a lot more negotiating power. Their shows are longer, they have way more ads. It's easy for them. So the whole idea of why we don't have highly crafted podcasts to the levels we used to is because it's all been flattened, because it just… it's so much easier for a comedian or celebrity to make them, and have way more impressions and be more attractive to podcast buyers who say:
[conversation panning]
Dallas: "Oh, you're gonna give me Conan O'Brien versus Twenty Thousand Hertz, which is way smaller?" "Oh, but they have a really high-quality show." "I don't care. Is it gonna result in sales? Give me Conan."
Dallas: That's an impossible thing to try to get through. So that's the fight that we have is: can we continue to make these incredibly expensive things when every celebrity has a podcast, every celebrity podcast is way bigger, and all the attention is not only on those podcasts, but they're also on scrolling on TikTok, Instagram. You got the YouTube of it all happening simultaneously. So the wind is blowing so hard against us.
[music out]
Of course, this is 2024, so we also have to compete with the political news cycle.
Dallas: Every time that there's an election, all the attention is gone. So we can never really be successful when everyone's attention is going into a black hole of attention. Everyone has limited time, and what are you gonna talk about between, "Oh, I heard this really cool story about the voices of Bluey," or, "Can you believe this? You know… That's dire.”
Dallas: Those type of situations just absolutely bury edutainment. It's the first thing to go. It's almost like we're just shouting into the void because of politics.
[music in: Wesley Slover - Nightfall Neighborhood]
By this point, our download numbers are down by a good twenty to thirty percent. It's harder than ever to book ads, and when we do book them, they don't pay nearly as much as they used to.
Dallas: And then the AI of it all starts to happen. The end of 2024, AI is starting to become a big, gigantic influence in the industry that I'm in, and where Defacto Sound lives.
Dallas: AI is now starting to become this thing that I think executives in the entertainment industry are just foaming at the mouth of how much money they can save by removing humans.
During this same period, the writers strike hit, the streaming boom slowed down, and companies pulled back from spending.
Dallas: And so as we progressed through 2024, financially across Defacto Sound and Twenty Thousand Hertz, we were getting lower and lower billings, and I was getting to the point where I stopped making money, and I was just trying to keep my team afloat because of all of these forces.
Dallas: But it became more and more clear as the holidays came, that “I can't keep draining every bit of savings that I've had for the past 15 years to keep everything afloat.” I was getting very close to just being zero across the board, like no future savings, nothing.
Dallas: By the beginning of 2025, we had had the biggest slowdown in Defacto Sound history. Up to that point, I had never, ever let someone go due to finances before. It was another point of pride. But I did have to lose, gosh, I think it was two people and a freelancer, because there was just no more money.
Dallas: And when you're running a business that has even six to 10 people, if you stop billing, the finances can turn upside down extremely quickly, and you could be in hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of debt which could be devastating.
Dallas: So yeah, it was just gut churn, and intensity, and almost just like walls closing in for months, until I went, "I can't, I don't know what's gonna happen." And I realize, “I've gotta end the show.”
[music out]
On February sixth, I called Casey to let him know. The next morning, I emailed the team, and included a long recording to explain the many reasons why I thought this had to be done. Here's some of that recording.
Dallas Loom: My wife talks about, like, “choosing your hard.” Everything will be hard in life. Job will be hard. Family life will be hard. There's gonna be friend situations that are hard. There are gonna be relationship things that are gonna be hard. So it's really a matter of “Choose the hard that… that fires you up the most.”
Dallas Loom: And Twenty Thousand Hertz is gonna remain hard if we continue doing it. And already starting to, like, seep into this… It's turning into a grind. Like, it's turning into a thing of just, like, every time we make one, I'm thinking 90% of the time of, “How do we even keep this show alive?” It's popping up in story reviews. All of this, these fears are kind of creeping higher and higher up. And I don't wanna live like that. I don't wanna put creative people through this, like, pain of, “This is probably not gonna exist.” I'd rather just have control.
Dallas Loom: I think when somebody makes something great and they can plan an ending, I think that that's a powerful thing. What I don't wanna do is grind through all of my savings, grind through, you know, episodes that on the surface seem so positive, but on the back end is just eating me away financially and… and kind of just working through fear.
Dallas Loom: So I'm extraordinarily proud of what we've been able to do for over 200 episodes in over eight and a half years. I feel content in what has been done. I feel very content in how we've been able to make something so special, that so many people identify with, that is important. And I'm so thankful for being able to highlight people who wouldn't be highlighted in other ways.
Dallas Loom: But there's so many strong headwinds ahead financially, attention-wise, algorithmically… so many things pushing against us so hard that I look down the road and I go, "I don't see a future. I don't see a way to grow. I don't see a way to, like, provide long term on this."
Dallas Loom: And so I know it's really kind of hard to process, and there's a lot that we'll all be feeling. I'm processing it myself. I've been processing it for many months, but I know this is gonna be something that'll, that we're all gonna be processing together.
[music in: Wesley Slover - The Work]
Dallas: Everyone got it. They could feel it, what was happening, with the finances. They could feel me, just how gut-churny I was, how sad I was. And the thing is, is everyone on this, this team is a fan of "Twenty Thousand Hertz." These are the people who even came to this organization because that was such a big part of it.
At the time, I’m completely convinced that this is what I have to do. But the thought of ending this thing that means so much to me is devastating. Especially because, right as this is happening, I get an invitation that I really have to consider.
Dallas: I get an offer to join the network of my dreams. First of all, I've been fiercely independent, if you will. I've never really wanted to join a network due to a lot of personal and business reasons. I wanted to control my own destiny and all of this stuff.
Dallas: But there was one network that reached out and said, "Hey, we'd like for you to join us." And it was the one that I had the most deep emotional connection with based off of the programming that had happened throughout its history, and what the current programming was, and what their future was.
Dallas: And so it was this weird point where I arrive at a podcast conference in Brooklyn, you know, they're just so excited and they're like, "We'd love to make this happen." And I'm like, "I'm sorry. I'm so depressed, and I don't think I'm gonna keep the show going, so there's just no way that this is gonna work out."
[music out]
Dallas: I even did a talk at that same conference where it was gonna be all about our workflow, just how we make the show from beginning to end.
Basically, the talk was about how we meticulously craft every episode over two to three hundred hours of labor.
Dallas: And when I started that talk, I completely said, "Look, I'm so proud of this, but this is also what's suffocating the show, and I've decided to end the show because of this."
Dallas: And so everyone kind of gasped, and then I went through all of this, but really just said, like, "This is not working. This is too much. I don't know what is the right thing to do, but this is too much."
When I came back from the conference, we started planning for the end.
Dallas: We had a runway of a few months to make just the best possible slate we could. We were gonna make May of 2025 the finale. I remember what episode I wanted to end on. It was the episode called, "The Autumn She's Been Hit." It's about a line in Halo, and it was about the person who delivered that line. It's my favorite episode. It's beautiful.
Dallas: And I wasn't gonna make a big fuss about it. I had planned on just playing that episode and just kind of saying, "That's the end. Thank you for listening. This has been a real pleasure and a privilege to do this."
[music in: Wesley Slover - Prism]
Throughout this process, I'd been thinking about other ways I could share my love of sound with the world.
Dallas: At the time, I just was frustrated with discoverability. The podcast is magical, but it is a closed loop. There is no people who discover it unless there's people going off and telling other people about it, and we just hadn't seen that. We'd seen a decline more than anything.
Dallas: You know, I can complain about it. I can't do anything to like force it to change. But what I can do is I can change how I'm approaching it. And I remember going, "Now's the time. I need to be telling stories in other ways where I can meet people where they are. Like the podcast is ending or likely ending. I don't wanna lose my voice.”
Dallas: I mean, I used to have nightmares about not being able to speak. I still occasionally have those, and I think it has to do with childhood, and trauma, and things like that. And, and so losing my voice was something that was really scary. I've always been worried about losing… or not being able to teach and not being able to show people this incredible world.
Dallas: And so that's when I started thinking, "Well, how do I make Twenty Thousand Hertz in video?" Well, making Twenty Thousand Hertz in video is impossible. It's not made for video. That storytelling style doesn't work in video. And even if I tried, it's oppressively expensive to actually make it compelling, and to even be anywhere close to the level of other YouTubers telling those type of stories.
Dallas: So I remember saying, "I gotta figure out something in video, but it can't be Twenty Thousand Hertz. It can't be something that takes 500 hours to make every single YouTube video."
[music out]
Dallas: So I started studying YouTubers, and I came across this YouTuber named Peter Santenello, who just holds an action cam and goes all around the world just meeting really fascinating people.
[clip: Peter Santenello - Amish]
Dallas: And I remember going, "Ooh, I love this. I love how authentic it is. I love how real it feels. I love how minimally edited it is. It's everything that AI is not.” And so I really just started studying Peter Santenello's style, where he was just holding a GoPro on a stick with two microphones that connected to it, and he was just, he was going around the world just talking to people in their spaces.
Dallas: And so I–I borrowed that exact system. I started buying little bits of gear and started, uh, reaching out. So I reached out to places like Jeopardy! and Saturday Night Live and some of these places saying, "Hey, I'm interested in doing a video version, kind of, uh, in the spirit of Twenty Thousand Hertz, but it won't be the same thing." And because, I guess, of all of this goodwill of years, I, and like everyone knew the podcast, and so they're like, "You're doing video? Yes, come in and do this!"
Dallas: So I started walking onto these sets and, and making these videos and getting all of this amazing access while the whole ship is sinking.
But as much as I love filming these videos, I still really don't wanna lose the podcast. And I find myself bargaining with the decision to end it.
Dallas: I started going, "What if I'm just not thinking of everything? What if I just reduce the amount of work that we have to do to make these episodes?" Is there any world where we can just float, just save it, just anything we can do to just get a few more months down the road? Because just at any point around the corner there could be a big project that holds this all together.
[music in: Wesley Slover - Flight]
So, we started seeing what we could do to slash those enormous production costs, while still putting out engaging stories. We ran a couple of episodes from other podcasts, and brought one of our old bonus subscription episodes into the main feed.
Dallas: Because we couldn't afford to make any episodes at this point. We're just in, like, full-blown survival mode.
Dallas: And then I asked Casey, I was like, "Can we just ask the audience for stories? I don't know if this is gonna work, but can we say ‘We're gonna do a… like a competition? You're going to make your own five-minute produced story in anything about sound and just send them to us. We'll put them in an episode.’" It wasn't a big brainstorming session.
Dallas: It wasn't this well-buttoned-up thing. It was literally, like, "Let's just put a promo on the next episode and, uh, here's what we'll do. We'll say, ‘We're gonna do this thing. Send us stories and, we'll rank them and, and play them.’"
So we put out the call.
[clip: Sound Off announcement]
Sound Off Announcement: That’s why we’re announcing a special competition, which we’re calling Sound Off. It’s your chance to craft a mini Twenty THousand Hertz episode that’ll be heard by over 100,000 people here on this feed.
Dallas: Yeah, I think we called it “Sound Off” competition at the time, and then we realized there's a company named that. Actually, a friend of mine owns a company called that, so we had to change it later.
Dallas: I also went to another conference where I just kind of recorded audio people telling these little mini stories. So I'm trying to just make things really less expensive.
Dallas: And it turns out that, like, making some things with humans actually n- without being super highly produced started to be entertaining in a way that I had never considered before. I think I was just scared for a long time to be me. And so I hid behind immense levels of production, and then I realized, “Wait a second, we're, like, killing the human here.
Dallas: Meanwhile, AI is becoming a bigger thing in this room. And AI flattens everything to almost this high production level that we had been doing already.
[music in: Wesley Slover - WFH Casual]
Dallas: So the Sound Off competition. Not a lot came back from that at first. And then when the deadline came up, we had, I think, 54 stories. We start going through them, and they're so good. So good.
Dallas: And I remember just having such a wave of emotion because that is what really was the turning point. I had never really asked for help, and I never really told the audience that I was asking for help, but I was asking for help by just seeing if other people could chip in and make some stories.
Here's a sample of the winning entry from that year.
[clip: Listener Story winner]
Francois: At home, we invented stories. I would sometimes read him books, but the pictures, they didn't really hold his attention. What mattered to him was sound. We would create characters, make funny voices, invent entire worlds, just by imagining.
[music resumes]
Dallas: Every time I hear these shows, I get so, like, weepy emotional over it, ’cause not only did we have enough for one show, we had enough for three full episodes, and they were some of the best episodes ever. And so this bought us a month and a half of time to be able to start to reorganize how we make shows.
Our financial struggles were far from over… but these listener stories gave us time to start plugging the holes in that sinking ship before it went completely under.
Dallas: So quite literally, the listener stories saved the podcast.
[music out]
Of course, I never publicly announced the end of the show, so our listeners had no idea any of this was happening.
Meanwhile, our new video series was ready to launch. I posted the first YouTube video on June 23, 2025. It was me going behind the scenes of Jeopardy with Production Sound Mixer Carlos Torres.
Carlos Torres: This is where the judges sit. We hold, I’d say a hundred, hundred and fifty people. We hold microphones hanging there to catch the audience reaction. People applaud and stuff like that, it’s a very important element of the show.
[music in: Wesley Slover - New Package]
Dallas: That first "Jeopardy!" went out, and it was very successful, like right away. And then "SNL," right after it was super successful. And then I think I went to Disneyland, and things that didn't cost a lot, and I was, I was also being really fulfilled as a person with these people breathing the same air that they're breathing.
Dallas: That was something that I hadn't experienced for all of these years of Twenty Thousand Hertz, because it's so remote. Right now I'm in a room by myself, talking into a microphone. But these felt like real connections. So the dopamine and the connection and the social bucket was being filled every single time I was an environment. And just the neurons that were connecting were neurons that I had never felt before.
Dallas: And I got really addicted to that. And through this process, the video kind of renewed the interest of the podcast, because then there was an excuse for people to go, "Wait, you're the host of Twenty Thousand Hertz. Oh yeah, everyone should go listen to Twenty Thousand Hertz." So it was almost like a calling card, even though it's a totally different format.
Dallas: Gosh, I mean, just month after month, it felt like everything started to fortify again, almost like how Twenty Thousand Hertz really transformed Defacto Sound early on 10 years ago, the video project kind of re-energized the Twenty Thousand Hertz podcast audience, but then also kind of started to re-fortify Defacto Sound just by being present more.
Dallas: Slowly but surely, as the video thing started to develop, the winds of the universe started blowing against my back because we'd get a project here or a project there, and it would slowly be just enough money to make the next payroll, and then things started creeping, like clawing back, just one by one. And it's been one step at a time ever since then.
Dallas: It was, as of this recording, 15 months ago when I put that first video out. And, um, there's been ups and downs, but our entire safety net at Defacto Sound has been rebuilt. That doesn't mean that we don't have weeks where we don't have very much coming in. Now, I know that there will be rocky roads ahead, uh, because there always has been. But we're in a place where everything seems stabilized.
[music out]
Dallas: And in that time, AI's gotten bigger and bigger. But the motto starting last year became, "Don't cut the human." In video and in podcast, “don't cut the human,” because we're fighting this kind of war, this Terminator war against AI coming in and doing all of the creative stuff.
Dallas: Like, I desperately want AI to come and do my dishes. I want AI to vacuum, and, like, cut my grass or something. I don't want AI pontificating about music or making music or art or podcasts or anything. I don't want AI doing that stuff. And it's weird how that's what what we're being sold on with AI. And it's just icky and gross.
Dallas: So how did I respond to that? Keep the awkward moments. Keep the time I, I sneezed in an episode and I go, "Did I just make a sneeze in Twenty Thousand Hertz? Did we actually do it?" And that's the moments of joy where I feel connection with people. We're doing a lot of things where someone is reporting to me, and I get to respond to it, and have conversation, and lift it into places that I'm an expert into as well.
Dallas: I, I, hesitate to just say it's gonna be more “conversational” because it's still gonna be very crafted. It's that Twenty Thousand Hertz is becoming more human, because sound is human. And I think it was a blind spot for a really, really long time, and it took AI to come through for me to go, "I hate this. I hate that it can even do a mildly good job at this." But do you know what it can't do? It can't sneeze in a podcast. It can't, like, make Grace laugh at this full belly laugh. And that's when I went, "Twenty Thousand Hertz needs to be that."
[music in: Wesley Slover - Contemplative Spirit X]
Dallas: I don't want the guiding principle of Twenty Thousand Hertz to be high production value. I want just as much information. I want just as much learning, edutainment. However, the other mandate is that I wanna have an experience making it. We will still do super highly crafted documentaries about sound when those topics need them.
Dallas: But when we do things that are like a game show, or we're doing something where someone's reporting something to me, the guiding principle is can someone learn just as much or more than they would've in the highly-crafted version of this while also smiling and laughing or tearing up or hearing a real human endearing moment that no one planned?
Dallas: That's the X factor is my joy, because I don't think the first nine years for me felt like joy. But the past year and a half of making Twenty Thousand Hertz when, basically I went, "It's all over anyway," has been… you know, it’s kind of like people who get a second lease on life.
[downbeat]
Dallas: Twenty Thousand Hertz was done, and ever since that moment I'm like, "I'm on borrowed time anyway, so if we're gonna do this, we're gonna have fun doing it."
Dallas: And then 10 years is here now. Here we are at 10 years, and that was my goal. “If I could make it for 10 years, I feel like that, that's a mark in podcasting history.” And from here on, I want to feel as much joy as I possibly can, but I wanna feel the emotions, not just try to craft them. I wanna feel them in real-time.
Dallas: I believe that some of our very best shows are ahead of us. But I wanna just be much more centered on who I am, and have experience, and connect with people. That's what I want Twenty Thousand Hertz to be moving forward.
[music out]
[music in: Wesley Slover - Everyday Symphony]
Twenty Thousand Hertz is produced by my sound agency, Defacto Sound. Hear more at Defacto Sound dot com.
Other Voices: This episode was written and produced by Katie Clark Gray, and Casey Emmerling, with help from Grace East. It was sound designed and mixed by Joel Boyter, with original music by Wesley Slover.
Finally, subscribe to my YouTube channel, Dallas Taylor dot mp3. Over there, I meet with audio experts in their creative spaces to unpack what they do. I've gone into Jad Abumrad's personal studio, behind the buzzers at America's Got Talent, backstage at Hamilton and Wicked, and so much more. You can also find short versions on Instagram, TikTok, Facebook and LinkedIn under that same name, Dallas Taylor dot mp3.
And from everyone here at Twenty Thousand Hertz, thank you for ten incredible years.
Thanks for listening.
[music out]
